How a Nightmare on Elm Street Reboot Can Actually Work Without Robert Englund’s Freddy Krueger

There is a new chapter coming to the A Nightmare on Elm Street movie series, but with the news that Robert Englund won’t be back as Freddy, many fans have already given up on the idea. The movie already received a reboot in 2010 with an incredible actor in the role of Freddy, but not even Jackie Earle Haley was able to win over the franchise’s fans as the new Dream Master. Of course, it wasn’t Haley who was the problem as much as a script that took things way too seriously and ignored the dark humor that made the franchise such a beloved slasher series.

It does bring up the idea that a reboot of A Nightmare on Elm Street could succeed without Robert Englund, but the script would have to be very different from the last movie.

A Nightmare on Elm Street Can Survive Without Robert Englund

The problem with the Nightmare on Elm Street reboot from 2010 wasn’t Jackie Earle Haley’s fault. This movie’s failure was a mixture of fans not expecting the movie to be good and then the film delivering a straight horror story without the humor that Freddy Krueger always delivered. The movie tried to take Wes Craven’s original movie that made Freddy into an icon and then retell the story with a scarier story and a more disturbing take. Instead of Freddy being a child killer, like Craven made him in the original movie, he was a child molester here. His goal was to punish the kids for revealing his dark secrets, and he killed all of them but Nancy (Rooney Mara) and a young man named Quintin (Kyle Gallner). Freddy’s face was also roughed up more to look like a burn victim.

The change in the movie from a dark comedy slasher into a straight horror scare fest doomed it. While the movie did bring in $115.7 million worldwide, it only made $63 million domestically, with a $35 million budget. Its critical response was rock bottom, with a 14% Rotten Tomatoes score and a low 43% audience rating. The critical consensus was that it lacked the depth and the subversive twists of the original movie. The audience reviews mostly complained about the movie being too serious and not scary enough, and that, more than the lack of Robert Englund, doomed it.

The Nightmare on Elm Street franchise can still succeed with a reboot, even without Englund, but it needs to get the story right first. Fans don’t want the movie to be a dark, serious horror story. They want it to be a fun movie about Freddy killing people in their dreams in subversive and disturbing ways. The best part about Freddy killing his victims was mocking them before killing them with their fears and failures. Freddy needs to be a scary killer, but he needs to do it in a fun way.

The entire path to A Nightmare on Elm Street coming back as a successful reboot is possibly to follow the footsteps of Scream in 2022. It is time to let Nancy go, and not even to bother with recasting her and telling that same story over again. We have already seen the story of Freddy and the parents who killed him, and his seeking revenge on their kids has been done twice already. It’s time to move on and take Freddy in a new direction. Maybe add in some new characters, as Scream did with Sam (Melissa Barrera) and Tara (Jenna Ortega). Let the new blood lead the fight against Freddy, while finding a unique reason to bring him back. If the franchise stops copying what came before, it can rise again, and it could do so without Robert Englund.

Robert Englund Could Still Theoretically Return

Robert Englund is 79 years old, so expecting him to play Freddy Krueger is bordering on ridiculous. Not only that, but Englund said that he refuses to sit for the makeup to play him again at his age. Englund said that if they wanted to do an animated version, he would voice him, but he won’t do anything that requires live-action scenes, and he said he is too old to even snap his head back anymore. Englund can’t and won’t play Freddy Krueger again in a live-action movie. Now, if they wanted to do an animated movie, that is another story.

That said, Englund also said that there are a lot of things the studio could do to make a new Nightmare on Elm Street work out well. He famously supported Jackie Earle Haley when he took on the role, even when Wes Craven showed his frustration at not being consulted on the film. Englund even said that the studio needs to find a new actor to carry this into the next generation, and he seemed excited about the new technology that is available for the nightmare sequences. Whether the fans accept a movie without him, though, is another story.

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!